Expired Listings in Colorado Springs: The Numbers and Your Second Attempt Skip to content

Strategic Selling Guide · Colorado Springs

Expired Listings in Colorado Springs: The Numbers and Your Second Attempt

November 2, 2026 6 min read By Juanita Simkins, Realtor & Advisor
More Colorado Springs listings ended 2025 unsold than in years, and expired counts ran at multi-year highs through 2026. Here is what the local data shows about why homes expire, and how to make a second attempt genuinely different.

A listing that ends without a sale is not a verdict on your home; it is feedback about the match between the price, the condition, the marketing, and the market at that moment. In Colorado Springs right now that situation is more common than it has been in years: Pikes Peak MLS data shows roughly three in ten listings did not produce a sale in 2025, and monthly expired counts ran at multi-year highs through 2026. This article walks through the numbers, the reasons behind them, and how to build a second attempt that is genuinely different from the first.

Key takeaways

  • Pikes Peak MLS data shows about 15,900 new listings in 2025 against about 11,100 closings, so roughly three in ten listings did not produce a sale that year, and 278 listings expired in Colorado Springs at the end of December 2025.
  • In a survey of top producing agents, 77 percent named pricing too high as the number one mistake that leaves homes unsold, and agents report that pricing just a few percent above where offers actually land sharply cuts showings.
  • The showing count, written feedback, offers, and price history from the first attempt are real data, and they point to the specific door to fix: price, condition, or exposure.
  • A second attempt only wins when it is different: a price set to today's comparables, condition and photos refreshed, and a marketing window that matches how long homes actually take to sell in the Springs.

What the local numbers show

In the Pikes Peak MLS, which covers El Paso County and parts of Teller County, 2025 closed with about 15,900 new listings and about 11,100 closed sales. The gap between those two numbers means roughly three out of every ten listings did not produce a sale that year, with some carrying into 2026. Local market reports tracking that MLS data counted 278 listings expiring in Colorado Springs at the end of December 2025 alone, and early 2026 reports said expired counts were running roughly double the year before, at multi-year highs.

The same current runs through the rest of the region, from Monument to Peyton to Fountain, all of which trade on the same MLS. And the pattern is not local to Colorado: Redfin counted 5.8 percent of all U.S. listings taken off the market without selling in April 2026, the highest share since March 2020, and industry tracking estimated about 78,000 listings expiring per week nationally, up about 83 percent from two years prior. The past year produced a lot of homes that did not sell, and the Springs was part of that wave.

First, a few definitions

'Expired', 'withdrawn', and 'stale' sound alike but mean different things. An expired listing is one whose listing agreement ran its full term without producing a sale. A withdrawn listing is one the seller pulled off the market early, and a stale listing is one that has sat 60 or more days without going under contract. The numbers differ by definition, which is why local and national reports can sound different. For a homeowner, the family of situations is the same: weeks or months of showings or silence, and no contract at the end of the term.

The number one reason: price

In a HomeLight survey of top producing agents, 77 percent named overpricing as the number one mistake that leaves homes unsold, and agents report that pricing a home just a few percent above supportable market value sharply reduces showings and, once a listing sits about 30 days, carries a stigma through the rest of the term. The same survey found 86 percent of agents trace an unsold home to price, condition, or marketing mistakes, and 44 percent said the costliest of those is waiting too long to cut the price.

A listing draws its strongest traffic in the first weeks of market exposure. In a slower local market, where homes in the Springs averaged around 53 days on the market in September 2026 and mortgage rates hovered near 7.4 percent, buyers compare more homes before choosing, and an asking price set above current comparables simply gets skipped. The home does not become less desirable; the number stops showing it to the buyers who can actually say yes.

The second door: condition and photos

Buyers meet a home online before they ever open its door. In the National Association of Realtors 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, 81 percent of buyers said listing photos were the most important feature in their online search, and 97 percent searched online during their home hunt. Outdated photos, cluttered rooms, and visible repairs all read instantly in a thumbnail.

Staging moves the same lever. In NAR's staging research, 81 percent of buyers' agents said staging helped buyers picture themselves living in the home, and staged homes tended to sell faster than unstaged ones. For a Colorado Springs seller, that usually means clearing, repairing the items buyers will notice, and re-photographing in real daylight rather than recycling the previous listing's images.

The third door: marketing and exposure

If few buyers ever toured, the door was exposure, not the home. Listings slide off the first pages of search results as they age, so a home that is not in front of the right buyers during its first weeks can burn its best window in silence. Small listing details matter more than sellers expect: how many photos, whether they were shot professionally, how the description reads, and whether showings are easy to book.

A sharp agent reads showings the way a doctor reads tests. Thirty families toured and no one wrote an offer? The price was the door. Barely anyone came? The exposure or the photos were the door. The distinction decides exactly what to fix.

Read the data you already own

The record from the first attempt belongs to you, and it is real market research. Most expired files contain at least one honest lesson, and often three. Review it as a system:

  • How many showings you had, and when they stopped coming.
  • The written feedback from touring buyers and their agents.
  • Any offers received, and which term stopped them from closing.
  • Where the list price sat against comparable sales at the time, not just what the home might be worth today.

What a genuinely different second attempt looks like

Relisting the same home on the same plan and hoping for a different result is the one strategy that reliably fails. A serious second try changes what the first attempt proved: the price is set from today's comparables, the condition pass reflects the showings feedback, the photos and marketing start fresh, and the showing schedule is real. In a market where homes average seven to eight weeks on the market, the second listing deserves the same runway the first one got, spent better.

For households who do not want another open-market cycle, Colorado Springs has alternative paths with different trade-offs: verified all-cash offers, trade-in programs, and sell-and-stay arrangements. They generally trade some price for certainty and speed, and they can be the right answer for a family on a deadline, such as a military move, a retirement move, or a transition tied to care.

When the home belongs to an estate

If the listing that expired is part of settling a loved one's estate, the diagnosis is the same but the stakes are higher: a vacant or dated home competes against well-prepared inventory, and every extra month of carrying costs comes out of the estate. Executors and trustees often benefit from the same reading of the data, plus a pricing and timing plan that fits the estate's own calendar.

This article is market information, not legal advice. Questions about who has authority to sell, what a will or trust allows, or how probate works for a specific estate should go to a qualified Colorado attorney. The questions are common; the answers are specific to the documents and the court.

The practical read

An expired listing is feedback, not a verdict. The local market is full of second attempts right now, and the ones that close are the ones that changed something real: the price, the condition, the photos, or the path itself. Start by reading the data from the first attempt, then decide which door to fix and set a date. A well-priced, well-prepared home sells in this market.

Juanita Simkins has priced and sold homes through every phase of the Springs market over 22 years, and she reviews expired listings like a case study: she will hand you a written diagnosis and a recommended price, whether you relist with her or not. Call 719-749-1601, email realtorjuanita@gmail.com, or book a consultation at https://www.calendly.com/JuanitaSimkins.

Portrait of Juanita Simkins

Written by Juanita Simkins

Realtor & Advisor, Broker Associate with eXp Realty in Colorado Springs. 22 years guiding local downsizing, estate, and probate transitions, including a Certified Probate Expert designation.

Keep reading

Your situation has details a guide cannot cover.

A short conversation with Juanita Simkins costs nothing and produces a clear plan: what your home is worth, what the next one should be, and how to get there.